# Discussing the Shades Of Gray Within Conflicts

- Link: https://instituteforglobalaffairs.org/2022/04/discussing-the-shades-of-gray-within-conflcts/
- Published: 2022-04-14T21:23:00-04:00

### By 󠀁[Zuri Linetsky](https://egfound.org/about/team/zuri-linetsky/)󠁿, Research Fellow

_**This contribution appeared i**_**_n the April 14, 2022 edition of “[Adults in a Room](https://inkstickmedia.com/discussing-the-shades-of-gray-within-conflicts/),”
a series from the Atlantic Council’s New American Engagement Initiative and_** _**
Inkstick**_.

---

As modern states evolved, they created [systems](https://ihl-databases.icrc.org/applic/ihl/ihl.nsf/Article.xsp?action=openDocument&documentId=473FCB0F41DCC63BC12563CD0051492D)
to [regulate](https://www.lawfareblog.com/did-former-green-berets-violate-1794-neutrality-act-invading-venezuela)
their behavior. States sought to eliminate all forms of non-state [violence](https://press.princeton.edu/books/paperback/9780691025711/mercenaries-pirates-and-sovereigns)
because it could unintentionally provoke interstate conflicts. But, states could
not [eliminate](https://time.com/6076035/erik-prince-ukraine-private-army/) all 
forms of non-state violence. Modern [gray zone](https://publications.armywarcollege.edu/pubs/2372.pdf)
[ operations](https://www.soc.mil/SWCS/SWmag/archive/SW2804/GrayZone.pdf) leverage
[gaps](https://harvardnsj.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/13/2021/02/HNSJ-Vol-12-Kiessling-Gray-Zone-Tactics-and-the-Principle-of-Non-Intervention.pdf)
in international law about the use of force and the principle of [non-intervention](https://www.chathamhouse.org/2019/12/application-international-law-state-cyberattacks/3-application-non-intervention-principle).
To operate in the gray zone, the US must address these gaps.

Gray zone operations confound international legal definitions of who is a [combatant](https://ihl-databases.icrc.org/customary-ihl/eng/docindex/v1_rul_rule3),
what is a [weapon](https://www.icrc.org/en/doc/assets/files/other/irrc_864_icrc_geneva.pdf),
and what constitutes a [war](https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/blogs/new-atlanticist/todays-wars-are-fought-in-the-gray-zone-heres-everything-you-need-to-know-about-it/)—
and they maximize [deniability](https://watermark.silverchair.com/iiy067.pdf?token=AQECAHi208BE49Ooan9kkhW_Ercy7Dm3ZL_9Cf3qfKAc485ysgAAArkwggK1BgkqhkiG9w0BBwagggKmMIICogIBADCCApsGCSqGSIb3DQEHATAeBglghkgBZQMEAS4wEQQMeRZiTvgsJzFtgHLQAgEQgIICbCfaQTDdN-8bfsPpzIiq_BBkWIB-2N7BD0MZ9jCwwJibUu3iq6b8nMY9XgoM9kylK3fnLB2G3BQscmP_BRh50DhoS1X06wqHXaZy4ebJdwLi4V2mNnPHhke-M9rkuPgGtfEr3lfy9rPmfDtbMfM6N2I0sVVhCt5Q8bZR1k9WWUK5eTAxjUmlUDT8-FhH7G29UETBAkI1XXIRhVr0CaUFkLYkSXtg1e91ycm_JMhvJWzBelSh27NZLuZBrGEVzCOaDKCfYDokEruRo-h_OnOTYU7xHDKn1aVQGx4z4z4czrr1k3X6-CtGp6QK2Z2LtLAfgIPGt3C-naCsWMVgbAdvTcVwnMLPKDmCiLmVPHebJrrtrNfT8eUR2FKIAfjm1SJXTGkij3DAKDlnNg42GbJG9nKWowxCLE-DoTEfIUv3UNsHTdyCD9eabWv3S61_R4CyxpoLYYrGQJ7cjuOcc8bDYQ40pK5aJKzueBtq-duxmRHkC5vduHtHAcE-SKpV_uxsSczQxTWhVimHXI3AG3PL-numeHlc_kMHDlO_Q0ie0FdnEaNOHmyurlOkbsXapIdIpvep4WCFN4F1j37h6qucGmWx8GkgdWMVGM9cVaR1sH4XZS-FyMuZTkmjCkX-nH01bKODzyxiwlb_pAKu_5lx_3JvdFrciqdSe_fV0DHt6qAK5nvcVrAY2B2S7pp6TegR9s2wzHbW2M0c4aOwtow-mxfUmxHLzRTm6PUlOKhwvXJlAcUq4BWeMP5ziGzISo_ayYYnJwxHUm96LW8_Ji3SQNYbPfIY4wloAsM77q0JMEG4g7UQpbGGnjSq_vVY)
for actors who implement them. Moreover, as large states successfully deploy gray
zone campaigns, smaller states have an incentive to [emulate](https://www.justsecurity.org/68622/punching-on-the-edges-of-the-grey-zone-iranian-cyber-threats-and-state-cyber-responses/)
them. These factors make gray zone operations a direct threat to the effectiveness
of international law.

_Read more of Zuri’s contribution in _[Inkstick](https://inkstickmedia.com/discussing-the-shades-of-gray-within-conflicts/).

---

[[

## **Written by **Zuri Linetsky

Zuri is a research fellow with the Independent America project at the Institute 
for Global Affairs.

 * [Twitter](https://twitter.com/ZuriLinetsky/)
 * [LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/in/zuri-linetsky/)

# Read more from Zuri

 [](https://instituteforglobalaffairs.org/2023/10/worldviews-data-backed-discoveries-on-americans-opinions/)

[Security](https://instituteforglobalaffairs.org/by-subject/security/)

### 󠀁[Worldviews: Data-Backed Discoveries on Americans’ Opinions](https://instituteforglobalaffairs.org/2023/10/worldviews-data-backed-discoveries-on-americans-opinions/)󠁿

 [](https://instituteforglobalaffairs.org/2023/10/vox-populi-order-and-disorder/)

[Politics & Government](https://instituteforglobalaffairs.org/by-subject/politics-government/)

### 󠀁[ORDER & DISORDER](https://instituteforglobalaffairs.org/2023/10/vox-populi-order-and-disorder/)󠁿

 [](https://instituteforglobalaffairs.org/2023/09/america-prepares-for-a-pacific-war-with-china-it-doesnt-want/)

[Security](https://instituteforglobalaffairs.org/by-subject/security/)

### 󠀁[America Prepares for a Pacific War With China It Doesn’t Want](https://instituteforglobalaffairs.org/2023/09/america-prepares-for-a-pacific-war-with-china-it-doesnt-want/)󠁿

[Diplomacy](https://instituteforglobalaffairs.org/by-subject/diplomacy/)

### 󠀁[Zuri Linetsky appeared on Radio Taiwan International’s The Strait Up Podcast on June 30, 2023](https://instituteforglobalaffairs.org/2023/06/zuri-linetsky-appeared-on-radio-taiwan-internationals-the-strait-up-podcast-on-june-30-2023/)󠁿

 [](https://instituteforglobalaffairs.org/2023/06/china-cant-catch-a-break-in-asian-public-opinion/)

[Diplomacy](https://instituteforglobalaffairs.org/by-subject/diplomacy/)

### 󠀁[China Can’t Catch a Break in Asian Public Opinion](https://instituteforglobalaffairs.org/2023/06/china-cant-catch-a-break-in-asian-public-opinion/)󠁿

[Politics & Government](https://instituteforglobalaffairs.org/by-subject/politics-government/)

### 󠀁[China in Context: What drives the US Republican Party’s agenda on China?](https://instituteforglobalaffairs.org/2023/06/china-in-context-what-drives-the-us-republican-partys-agenda-on-china/)󠁿

 [](https://instituteforglobalaffairs.org/2023/06/modeling-democracy-caught-in-the-middle/)

[Politics & Government](https://instituteforglobalaffairs.org/by-subject/politics-government/)

### 󠀁[Caught in the Middle](https://instituteforglobalaffairs.org/2023/06/modeling-democracy-caught-in-the-middle/)󠁿

[Security](https://instituteforglobalaffairs.org/by-subject/security/)

### 󠀁[Zuri Linetsky appeared on Voice of America on June 7, 2023](https://instituteforglobalaffairs.org/2023/06/zuri-linetsky-appeared-on-voice-of-america-on-june-7-2023/)󠁿

[Security](https://instituteforglobalaffairs.org/by-subject/security/)

### 󠀁[China in Context: Canda’s Clashes with China](https://instituteforglobalaffairs.org/2023/06/egf-research-fellow-zuri-linetsky-on-china-in-context/)󠁿
